Britton Smith and Ensemble (Photo by Jeff Lorch)
Reviewed by F. Kathleen Foley
Pasadena Playhouse
Through November 29
RECOMMENDED

Britton Smith, Ty Taylor and Tanerélle (Photo by Jeff Lorch)
Some 20 years after its short but heralded run on Broadway, Passing Strange finally arrives in Southern California.
The long-awaited musical, now at the Pasadena Playhouse, premiered at Berkeley Rep in 2006. It received multiple awards and nominations in the 2008 New York season, including a Tony win for Best Book. Spike Lee’s film of the production aired on PBS in 2010.
The autobiographically based story, whose title derives from Othello, traces the artistic progression of its creator, Stew, who wrote the book and lyrics and composed the music with his longtime creative partner, Heidi Rodewald. (Annie Dorsen, the show’s original director, is also credited as a collaborator.)
By all accounts, the show’s intensely personal nature, made even more personal by Stew’s own reportedly galvanic performance as the Narrator, helped make Passing Strange a crowd and critical favorite.
Today, the show falls just short of its past promise. Despite its numerous virtues, which include lively direction by Zhailon Levingston, the recent Tony winner for his co-direction of a heavily revised Cats;Ty Taylor in a mesmerizing turn as the Narrator; and a terrific onstage band helmed by keyboardist and music director Greg Nabours, Passing seems part of a then-zeitgeist whose time has, indeed, passed.
The action revolves around the peregrinations of a Youth (Britton Smith), a wannabe musician and songwriter from South Central who leaves his Mother (Saycon Sengbloh) and the “plastic land” of L.A. to pursue his craft in Europe.
His first stop takes him to Amsterdam, where he engages in a drug-fueled liaison with beautiful Marianna (Tanerélle), who welcomes him into her colorful “family” of hedonists. (The constant pleasure-seeking cloys.) Proclaiming that “Paradise is a bore,” he departs for Berlin, exchanging his free-wheeling Amsterdam clan for a new coterie of fanatical revolutionaries. Truckling for acceptance, he portrays himself as a persecuted Black man oppressed by the American system. (He’s actually solidly middle-class.) His German lover, Desi (Brittany Campbell), calls him out for “passing for ghetto” — adopting a mask that shields his authentic self. All the while, his loving mother urges him to return home to L.A. and his real family.
His inwardly directed, self-absorbed “hero’s journey” is more a portrait of the artist as a selfish young man. In any event, his search is overlong, and indeed the interlude in Amsterdam could arguably have been wholly elided without interrupting the narrative flow.
It’s puzzling that such a patchwork plot earned the show’s sole Tony for book, when the lyrics are much more clever and poetic. Although hampered by an imperfect sound design, the strong-voiced cast, which includes Johnny Laveie and Devere Rogers, vigorously personify the youthful spirit of the piece. As the hero realizes, the dreams of youth are sadly perishable. Older and wiser, he is astonished to realize that an entire life can be determined by the decisions made as a teenager — and a stoned teenager at that.
You can see the ending coming a mile down a straight country road, but despite its predictability, the final scenes floor you with unexpected emotion. The young protagonist’s message, “Love is a mistake that only art can correct,” resounds. More resonant is the inference that the blind pursuit of art, at the cost of that love, may be too heavy a price to pay.
Speaking of zeitgeist, timing is, after all, everything. The action commences in 1976, one year after the fall of Saigon. One suspects that the efforts of this “fiery pilgrim” to find himself may have had a wholly different outcome a few short years previously. There’s something voluptuous about the Youth’s tireless seeking of his true self across time and continents. Not all youths are as fortunate.
Pasadena Playhouse, 39 S. El Molino Ave., Pasadena; Fri.-Sat., 8 pm, Sat.-Sun., 2 pm, Sun., 7 pm, Wed.-Thurs., 7:30 pm; thru Nov. 29. 626-356-7529, https://www.pasadenaplayhouse.org Runtime: two hours and 30 minutes with an intermission.












